Wednesday, 22 April 2015

Critical Analysis

"Whatever it grants to vision and whatever its manner, a photograph is always invisible; it is not it that we see." R. Barthes.

As soon as people looked at a photograph, we believed that it is what was seen by the photographer. As Berger pointed out:

"Perspective makes the single eye the centre of the visible world. Everything converges on the eye as to the vanishing point of infinity." (Berger 2008:18)

However:

"The invention of the camera changed the way men saw. The visible came to mean something different to them." (Berger 2008:18)

Now, we see photographs as creations. They have been carefully designed and created, rather than captured. I have illustrated this very technique in my project, capturing ordinary landscape photos, editing them and adding characters from folklore that do not belong in our time, perhaps even in the real world. My creations have placed these characters in real-life settings, however:

"An image is a sight which has been recreated of reproduced. It is an appearance, or a set of appearances, which has been detached from the place and time in which it first made its appearance and preserved - for a few moments or a few centuries." (Berger 2008:10)

By situating images of mythical creatures within contemporary landscapes, I have brought them to life. Though I have not forgotten that the images are fictional, the effect that they have upon the audience will be real. If the audience is encouraged to think and see the possibility of more in the world, of adventure and mystery in everyday life, then the project has succeeded to break the mundane routines of modern living, flavouring life with centuries-old secrets.

"It is seeing which establishes our place in the surrounding world" Berger (2008:7)


-Barthes, R. [trans.] Howard, R. (1982) Camera Lucidia: Reflections on Photography. New York: Hill and Wang.
-Berger, J. (2008) ‘Chapter 1’ Ways of Seeing. London: British Broadcasting Corporation and Penguin Books, pp. 7-34.


Field Trip

These are snapshots from the PDF contact sheet of our field trip to Stanmer Park early in the term (PDFs cannot be uploaded to Blogger). I was attempting to display the ways in which light changes the environment. I began taking photos before the sun had fully risen; the light was dull. Then, as the sun rose, it shone through leaves, making them glow; it was reflected by the shimmering water in the pond full of litter, making it somehow beautiful; it lit up the landscape in unusual and enchanting ways. Perhaps the mystical auora it created helped to inspire my mythical project. The light made small, dark hollows in a hedgerow look like a fairy den by lighting the leaves around the opening: light changes perspective. This was something that I could utilise in my project. I found this during the Devil's Dyke shoot - the landscape was a dull purple until the sun rose and filled it with golden light.
This again relates back to Ways of Seeing, by John Berger. "The more imaginative the work, the more profoundly it allows us to share the artist's experience of the visible." My aim for the project was to inspire people to look at the world differently, to see more of the mystical qualities of the world rather than plough through the streets with headphones on, missing these experiences. Whatever people believe about myths and folktales, they teach us important lessons and the element of mystery is important in life. People can be naive enough to believe that we know all there is to know about the world, that there is no such thing as mystery, but that will never be true and things should stay that way.












Final Mount Caburn Fairies

1/100    5.6    ISO 100

"There is also riveting folk tale about a mouth organist called Charlie Winnick who was supposed to have been one of the best players during the interwar years. 
But when he was young, he was a terrible player and bullied by some other children, who took his mouth organ and threw it into a field. 
Having scrambled through the field to find his mouth organ, he goes to sit and enjoy a quiet moment of reflection, but sees a scarecrow in the field in front of him move its arms. 
The scarecrow then flies him inside Mount Caburn, where the pharisees (Sussex dialect for fairies) teach him to play the mouth organ exquisitely.
When he returns home the next day, the boys who bullied him have been given a good thrashing and his parents are relieved to see him.
Of course they don’t believe his story about the pharisees but no one can deny his improved ability at the mouth organ."


  • http://www.sussexexpress.co.uk/news/county-news/sussex-folk-tales-and-myths-reveal-world-of-ghosts-and-fairies-1-5371055 

Final St. Leonard's Forest Dragon

Background      1/20      9.0      ISO 100
Dragon      1/125      7.1      ISO 100

"Although St Leonard cannot be truly claimed as a Sussex saint (he was a French hermit of the sixth century, later often revered by returning Crusaders who believed in his power to save them from captivity), a very long-standing legend asserts that he did actually live for many years in St Leonard's Forest, near Horsham, and moreover that he once killed a dragon there. The battle was long and ferocious, and as a reward for Leonard's courage, Heaven granted that wild lilies of the valley would spring ip for ever wherever his blood had sprinkled the earth, and that nightingales which had previously distracted him by their singing while he was at prayer would henceforth be silent."


  • Simpson, J (2009) Folklore of Sussex. Third edition. Gloucestershire: The History Press.

Final Witch

1/30        6.3       ISO 100

"It was firmly believed that any witch could turn into a hare as soon as she was alone and unobserved. In proof of this, it was often alleged that the local huntsmen had repeatedly sighted a hare, chased it, and failed to catch it because it had disappeared into the garden of some particular old woman, or bolted into her drain. It the huntsmen knocked at her door, they would find her at home, but panting. This went on till one day one of the hounds snapped at the hare's hindquarters as it fled - and when next seen, the old woman was nursing a wounded leg."


  • Simpson, J (2009) Folklore of Sussex. Third edition. Gloucestershire: The History Press.

I had considered photoshopping a hare into the image of the witch, but it was difficult with all the undergrowth in the churchyard. I captured what I imagined the old lady, out of breath and nursing her wounded leg might look like. This is a more realistic representation that its stereotypical counterparts in the series. She is not dressed in rags, covered with wrinkles or transforming from a hare into an old woman, this is more subtle, but still effective.

Final Michelham Priory Ghost

1/125         7.1         ISO 100

"Commonly known as the Grey Lady, this is probably the best known of the priory's ghosts, and the one spotted most often, although, ironically, there is much disagreement as to her identity.

According to Andrew Green, a couple of friends of the Beresford-Wrights were enjoying a quiet walk around the grounds one summer evening when they noticed a woman standing on the bridge in front of the gatehouse. Dressed in a grey gown, the woman had a sad expression on her face as she gazed into the moat beneath her. When the couple later asked their hosts about the identity of 'the other guest', they were assured that they were the only visitors staying at Michelham at that time. Over the next few months other the visitors to the priory reported seeing the same sad-looking woman."

  • Munn, D (2006) Sussex Haunted Heritage. Sussex: S.B. Publications.

Final Long Man of Wilmington Giant

1/200         6.3        ISO 100

"The tallest man in England is a Sussex man - the famous Long Man of Wilmington, a gigantic figure, 226 feet long, cut in the turf on the steep northern flank of Windover Hill, facing Wilmington Priory.

The giant must have remained locally popular, for only repeatedly scraping away the turf could have kept him in existence through the centuries so that he survived, however dimly, until he was given his permanent outline in late Victorian times. Scouring such a large figure must have been a considerable task, and it is probably fair to assume that it was a communal undertaking, enlivened by sports and merrymaking (as at the famous scouring of the While Horse of Uffington, in Berkshire), but unfortunately no records of such activity have survived.

Naturally, a local legend grew up to explain how such a figure was there at all. According to this a living giant had once had his home on Windover Hill, but had been killed, and the figure was either a memorial to him to the actual outline of his body, drawn round him as he lay dead on the slope."


  • Simpson, J (2009) Folklore of Sussex. Third edition. Gloucestershire: The History Press.